A green line, painted around the perimeter of the World Trade Center (WTC) site, defined the recovery area. Within and around this boundary, OSHA worked for 10 months with its partners in safety and health to protect the well-being of workers on the site. Within that space, no workers lost their lives in the recovery effort that followed the tragedy of September 11, 2001.
OSHA’s strategy at the WTC was to pursue collaboration while suspending enforcement and providing consultation, guidance, and technical assistance with a sound safety and health plan. Our goal from the start was protection, not citation.
From the very beginning, OSHA knew that the recovery of the WTC site would be no ordinary demolition project. At the center stood a mountain —all that remained of two skyscrapers that once soared 110 stories high and defined the New York City skyline for decades.
OSHA had addressed many of these hazards before, but not on such a vast scale. No one could deal with the catastrophe alone. No one group had all of the answers, equipment, experience—let alone the personnel—to protect the safety and health of workers at the site. How would they accomplish that goal? The answer lay in partnership.
Informal collaboration of initial responders had begun early. But soon, representatives from every group involved in the recovery effort would formally agree to join in a team effort to protect the safety and health of workers at the disaster site.
Secretary of Labor Elaine Chao led the signing of the formal partnership. Speaking at the ceremony in New York City on November 20, 2001, Chao declared, “American workers—from city, state, and federal government agencies, trade associations, contractors, and labor organizations—formed a partnership to reclaim this site and recover our fellow citizens. They’ve done this with pride, dignity, talent, hard work, and dogged determination.”
A flood of workers soon poured onto the site. Here is a partial list:
• Asbestos Workers
• Cement Masons
• Construction Managers
• Emergency Medical Technicians
• EPA employees
• FEMA workers
• Fire Fighters
• Heavy Equipment Operators
• Insulation Workers
• Medical Doctors and Coroners
• National Guard
• NIOSH employees
• Office Cleaners
• OSHA staff
• Plumbers and Pipefitters
• Police Officers
• Red Cross workers
• Registered Nurses
• Rescue Workers
• Safety and Health Professionals
• Sheet Metal Workers
• Structural Engineers
• Truckers and Teamsters
Signatories to the World Trade Center Emergency Project Partnership Agreement:
• AMEC Construction Management, Inc. • Bovis Lend Lease LMB, Inc.
• Building and Construction Trades Council of Greater New York (BCTC)
• Building Trades Employers’ Association (BTEA)
• Contractors Association of Greater New York (CAGNY)
• Fire Department of New York (FDNY)
• General Contractors Association (GCA)
• New York City Department of Design and Construction (DDC)
• Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
• Tully Construction Company, Inc.
• Turner/Plaza Construction Joint Venture
IDENTIFYING RISKS AND HAZARDS
Many hazards threatened the safety and health of site workers. They included risks caused by cranes lifting beams of unknown weight and improperly handled compressed gas cylinders that might explode, as well as threats posed by falls and falling objects, hot steel, confined spaces, Freon, and much more.
A list of the most dangerous risks facing the WTC recovery workers follows:
Identifying Risks and Hazards: CRANES
More than 30 cranes, including some of the largest in the world, were at work in uncomfortably close quarters inside the green line. In what has been described as an intricate balance of motion and timing, the cranes lifted loads of twisted steel and compacted rubble in an environment fraught with the potential for accidents. High winds, rain, unstable ground, and uncertain loads added to this dangerous mix.
OSHA saw the need for special focus to address the growing concern over crane operations. The agency consulted with various partners and then launched a Joint Crane Inspection Task Force. Composed of representatives from OSHA, contractors, and the International Union of Operating Engineers (IUOE), the task force spent two days inspecting 17 cranes inside the green line. They found numerous serious hazards on more than half the cranes. Most of the hazards involved crane set-up, rigging, and hoisting practices. Crane set-up continued to be an issue because the giant steel towers often rested on unstable platforms as fires burning deep in the pile caused the cranes to shift. The task force identified hoisting personnel with man-baskets as the most serious concern. For example, in the early days of the recovery, workers modified garbage dumpsters with welding torches, then hooked them to cranes to lower workers into the pile.
Identifying Risks and Hazards: HEAVY EQUIPMENT
The combination of rescue workers performing recovery operations side by side with demolition workers using heavy equipment in tight quarters and under great emotional stress posed unique challenges. Ordinarily, rescue workers are not present when machines such as excavators, grapplers, and debris trucks are operating. This was not the case here. OSHA consulted with construction personnel, labor representatives, and emergency responders to find a simple solution that made a big difference. The wearing of brightly colored reflective vests made the workers visible to the equipment operators and reduced the potential for serious injury or even death. A mandatory distance between rescue workers and heavy equipment provided additional protection.
The sheer size and instability of the debris pile posed further complications. The mountain of mangled debris rose six stories above ground and descended seven below; voids within caused ever-changing shifts and constant hazards. With heavy equipment operating on such unstable surfaces, there was special cause for concern. Yanking twisted steel from one spot could undermine another and send an operator into a hole several stories deep. Safety officials worried daily about the potential for such falls. They kept a close eye on the number of workers operating heavy equipment and on their proximity to others working on the pile. There were many “near misses,” including an unattended crane that fell 30 feet when the platform of rubble on which it sat gave way. Constant vigilance—and in a few cases, fate and good luck—averted near disaster.
Identifying Risks and Hazards: EXPLOSIONS
Numerous compressed gas cylinders used by burners to cut steel beams and rebar were scattered around the site. These cylinders included oxygen and acetylene tanks, both extremely hazardous if not handled properly. In the early days of the rescue effort, these tanks were largely unsecured, lying haphazardly on the ground. To reduce this hazard, OSHA joined forces with the Fire Department of New York to patrol the site and ensure that contractors followed proper storage and handling procedures.
The potential for explosions was always present at the site. In one case, a fuel tank with tens of thousands of gallons of diesel fuel was buried seven stories below ground. With smoldering fires, a rupture could have been disastrous. Once workers located the tank, it was safely emptied, and the fuel was removed from the site.
The parking garage under the WTC held nearly 2,000 automobiles, each tank holding an estimated five gallons of gasoline. When recovery workers reached the cars, they found that some had exploded and burned while others remained intact.
Building 6, the former site of OSHA’s Manhattan Area Office, housed many federal agencies, including the U.S. Customs Service. More than 1.2 million rounds of their ammunition, plus explosives and weapons, were stored in a third-floor vault to support their firing range. OSHA worked closely with other government agencies to determine what protective measures were necessary so that the ammunition could be safely removed.
Another danger involved the high temperature of twisted steel pulled from the rubble. Underground fires burned at temperatures up to 2,000 degrees. As the huge cranes pulled steel beams from the pile, safety experts worried about the effects of the extreme heat on the crane rigging and the hazards of contact with the hot steel. And they were concerned that applying water to cool the steel could cause a steam explosion that would propel nearby objects with deadly force. Special expertise was needed. OSHA called in structural engineers from its national office to assess the situation. They recommended a special handling procedure, including the use of specialized rigging and instruments to reduce the hazards.
Identifying Risks and Hazards: FREON
Huge underground tanks held more than 200,000 pounds of Freon stored to cool the seven buildings of the WTC complex. This had been the largest air-conditioning system in the country.
OSHA personnel were concerned that workers entering areas below grade could be exposed to Freon gas, a known, heavier-than-air, invisible killer. After a leaking tank was discovered, agency staff and the site construction manager carried out special sampling for months until all the tanks were uncovered and safely removed.
Identifying Risks and Hazards: CONFINED SPACE
OSHA has investigated hundreds of cases of carbon monoxide poisoning across the country. Often this hazard is not immediately apparent, and what may seem to be an open-air atmosphere is really a more deadly confined space. Rescue and recovery workers entered collapsed buildings where the atmospheric hazards from fire and toxic fumes could have been fatal.
Besides the usual hazards in confined spaces, the site conditions at the WTC posed the additional risk of structural instability. The DDC designated certain areas for special attention. For example, a sudden and catastrophic release of Freon could overcome workers performing demolition and recovery operations inside collapsed buildings. OSHA helped DDC establish safe entry protocols for these areas.
OSHA’s commitment to the WTC recovery involved more than 1,000 agency employees working 24 hours a day, seven days a week, alongside other federal, state and local agencies to ensure the safety and health of workers at the site. At the height of this effort, 75 OSHA staff worked the site each day and OSHA personnel provided more than 15,000 work shifts.
• Collected more than 6,500 air and bulk samples to test for asbestos, lead, other heavy metals, silica, and various organic and inorganic compounds.
• Conducted more than 24,000 evaluations of worker exposure.
• Conducted sampling around-the-clock.
• Distributed more than 131,000 respirators, 11,000 hard hats, 13,000 safety glasses and goggles, and more than 21,000 pairs of protective gloves.
• Identified more than 9,000 hazards.
After September 11, 2001, not one life was lost inside the green line during the recovery effort.
OSHA learned a great deal at the WTC site, lessons that can help the agency improve its own emergency preparedness while also helping employers prepare for emergency response.
EMPLOYER EMERGENCY EVACUATION PLANS
OSHA suggests that workplaces review and practice their plans with an emphasis on the following:
• Finding alternate exits.
• Accounting for all employees.
• Designating alternate rendezvous points.
• Developing procedures for the disabled.
EMERGENCY RESPONSE PART N E RS H I PS
Emergency response partnerships, with clear lines of authority for all functions at a site and with special emphasis on safety and health, should be created immediately to promote effective disaster site management.
In addition, OSHA recommends the following as key elements for emergency response partnerships to consider in planning for disasters:
For first responders and federal law enforcement agencies:
• Develop outreach and training materials.
• Address safety and health issues related to incidents involving terrorism and weapons of mass destruction.
Emergency responders, managers, and incident commanders should:
• Plan for emergency responses.
• Ensure early and complete implementation of the incident command system (ICS) and/or Unified Command at all incidents.
• Designate safety officers with no collateral duties and sufficient authority.
• Conduct comprehensive site risk assessments.
• Make safety and health protections a priority.
• Protect employees from job hazards.
• Install proper shoring.
• Pay attention to material handling equipment and rigging.
• Monitor worksites for health risks.
• Consider environmental conditions, stress, and fatigue.
• Control access to the site.
• Manage volunteers effectively.
• Manage donations, especially unsolicited in-kind goods.
Emergency responders at all levels of government should be routinely fit-tested for respirators.
• Improve channels of communication with other local, state, and federal agencies.
• Improve emergency communication capability.
• Coordinate access to military transportation.
• Plan for emergency transportation.
OSHA continues to work with other federal agencies across government to improve cooperation and collaboration in the event that a coordinated response on such a massive scale is ever needed again. If the need arises, OSHA will be ready.